
RRB NTPC Graduate Level Result 2025: Key Updates, Cut-Off Marks, and Next Steps

The much-awaited RRB NTPC Graduate Level Result 2025 has been released, bringing clarity for lakhs of aspirants across India. Here’s a detailed analysis of the results, cut-off trends, and what comes next.
Table of Contents
The Railway Recruitment Board (RRB) is expected to announce the NTPC Graduate Level Result 2025 in September 2025 following the completion of Computer Based Test 1 (CBT-1). This recruitment cycle offers 8,113 graduate-level positions as part of the larger Non-Technical Popular Categories (NTPC) recruitment drive totaling 11,558 vacancies across Indian Railways.
Understanding RRB NTPC Recruitment: Purpose and Overview
The RRB NTPC recruitment serves as the primary gateway for non-technical graduate and undergraduate positions within Indian Railways. The Railway Recruitment Board conducts this centralized examination to fill various administrative, clerical, and operational positions across different railway zones throughout India.
This recruitment process evaluates candidates through multiple assessment stages. The examination structure includes Computer Based Tests, skill assessments, document verification, and medical examinations. The comprehensive evaluation ensures selection of qualified candidates for diverse railway operations.
Indian Railways employs over 1.2 million personnel across its network. The NTPC recruitment addresses staffing requirements for commercial, operational, and administrative functions. This examination cycle represents one of the significant employment opportunities in the public sector.
RRB NTPC 2025: Vacancy Distribution and Position Details
The current recruitment cycle announces 11,558 total vacancies distributed between graduate and undergraduate categories. Graduate level positions account for 8,113 openings, while undergraduate level comprises 3,445 positions.
Graduate Level Position Categories
Station Master: This position involves managing railway station operations, train scheduling, and passenger services. Station Masters coordinate platform activities, signal operations, and emergency response procedures. The role requires decision-making capabilities and operational knowledge.
Goods Train Manager: Goods Train Managers oversee freight train operations and cargo management. Responsibilities include coordinating loading operations, maintaining documentation, and ensuring timely delivery of freight consignments. The position requires understanding of goods traffic regulations.
Junior Accounts Assistant: Junior Accounts Assistants handle financial transactions, bookkeeping, and budget management. The role involves maintaining financial records, processing payments, and preparing financial reports. Candidates need numerical aptitude and accounting knowledge.
Commercial Clerk: Commercial Clerks manage ticketing operations, revenue collection, and customer service. Responsibilities include handling passenger inquiries, processing reservations, and maintaining commercial records. The position requires customer interaction skills.
Traffic Clerk: Traffic Clerks coordinate train movement, maintain operational logs, and communicate with control rooms. The role involves monitoring train schedules, updating movement registers, and ensuring operational compliance.
Salary Structure and Pay Scale
| Position Level | Starting Monthly Salary | Pay Level |
|---|---|---|
| Graduate Level Posts | ₹29,200 | Level 6 |
| Undergraduate Posts | ₹21,700 | Level 2 |
The salary figures represent basic pay as per 7th Pay Commission recommendations. Additional allowances include Dearness Allowance (DA), House Rent Allowance (HRA), and Travel Allowance (TA) based on posting location.
CBT-1 Examination Details: Schedule and Structure
The Computer Based Test 1 for RRB NTPC 2025 was conducted from August 7, 2025, to September 9, 2025, across multiple examination centers nationwide. The examination spanned 34 days to accommodate the large candidate pool.
CBT-1 Examination Pattern
Test Duration: 90 minutes (120 minutes for PwD candidates with scribe facility)
Total Questions: 100 multiple-choice questions
Total Marks: 100 marks (1 mark per question)
Negative Marking: 0.33 marks deducted for each incorrect answer
Subject-wise Question Distribution
| Subject | Number of Questions | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| General Awareness | 40 | 40 |
| Mathematics | 30 | 30 |
| General Intelligence & Reasoning | 30 | 30 |
| Total | 100 | 100 |
General Awareness covers current affairs, Indian history, geography, economics, general science, and Indian constitution. Questions assess candidates’ knowledge of national and international developments.
Mathematics includes arithmetic, algebra, geometry, trigonometry, and basic statistics. The section tests numerical ability and problem-solving skills at graduate level.
General Intelligence & Reasoning evaluates logical reasoning, analytical ability, and pattern recognition. Question types include analogies, coding-decoding, series completion, and logical deductions.
RRB NTPC Result 2025: Declaration Process and Access Methods
The Railway Recruitment Board announces results through official websites for each RRB zone. Results become accessible simultaneously across all regional portals to ensure uniform access.
Result Access Procedure
Step 1: Visit Official Portal Navigate to the official RRB website for your examination zone. The primary portal for centralized information is rrbcdg.gov.in (Railway Recruitment Board, Chandigarh).
Step 2: Locate Result Link Find the “RRB NTPC Graduate Level CBT-1 Result 2025” link on the homepage. The link appears under the “Latest Updates” or “Results” section.
Step 3: Enter Credentials Provide your registration number and date of birth in the specified format. Some portals may require additional verification through captcha codes.
Step 4: View and Download Result The system displays your result status, normalized marks, and qualification status. Download the scorecard PDF for future reference.
Step 5: Save Documentation Store downloaded result documents in multiple locations (email, cloud storage, physical printout). These documents will be required for subsequent selection stages.
Regional RRB Websites
Candidates should access results through their respective examination zone websites:
- RRB Ahmedabad: rrbahmedabad.gov.in
- RRB Ajmer: rrbajmer.gov.in
- RRB Allahabad: rrbald.gov.in
- RRB Bangalore: rrbbnc.gov.in
- RRB Bhopal: rrbbpl.nic.in
- RRB Bhubaneswar: rrbbbs.gov.in
- RRB Bilaspur: rrbbilaspur.gov.in
- RRB Chandigarh: rrbcdg.gov.in
- RRB Chennai: rrbchennai.gov.in
- RRB Gorakhpur: rrbguwahati.gov.in
Additional zones include Kolkata, Mumbai, Patna, Ranchi, Secunderabad, Siliguri, and Thiruvananthapuram. Candidates should bookmark their specific zone portal for direct access.
Understanding Cut-off Marks: Category-wise Analysis
Cut-off marks represent the minimum qualifying scores required for CBT-2 eligibility. The Railway Recruitment Board determines cut-offs based on multiple factors including vacancy numbers, candidate performance, and reservation policies.
Factors Affecting Cut-off Determination
Vacancy Distribution: Higher vacancies in specific zones may result in relatively lower cut-offs. Zones with limited positions typically record higher qualifying marks.
Candidate Performance: Overall examination performance affects normalization and cut-off setting. Strong candidate pools push cut-off marks higher.
Question Difficulty: Examination difficulty level influences scoring patterns. The normalization process accounts for variations across different examination sessions.
Reservation Policy: Separate cut-offs for each category ensure equitable representation. Constitutional reservation provisions guide category-wise qualifying marks.
Expected Cut-off Ranges (Indicative)
| Category | Expected Cut-off Range | Percentage |
|---|---|---|
| General (UR) | 68-75 marks | 68-75% |
| OBC (Other Backward Classes) | 63-70 marks | 63-70% |
| SC (Scheduled Castes) | 58-65 marks | 58-65% |
| ST (Scheduled Tribes) | 55-62 marks | 55-62% |
| EWS (Economically Weaker Sections) | 65-72 marks | 65-72% |
These ranges represent estimates based on historical trends and current recruitment parameters. Actual cut-offs will be published with official results.
Zone-wise Cut-off Variations
High Competition Zones: Northern Railway, Central Railway, and Western Railway zones typically record higher cut-offs. These zones include major metropolitan areas with large candidate populations and premium posting locations.
Moderate Competition Zones: Southern Railway, South Central Railway, and Eastern Railway maintain balanced cut-offs. These zones offer substantial vacancies with competitive but manageable qualifying standards.
Relatively Lower Competition Zones: Northeast Frontier Railway and certain regional zones may have comparatively lower cut-offs. Limited candidate density in these regions affects competition intensity.
CBT-2 Examination: Next Selection Stage
Candidates qualifying CBT-1 based on cut-off marks advance to Computer Based Test 2. The number of candidates shortlisted equals 20 times the total vacancies for each category and post.
CBT-2 Examination Structure
Test Duration: 90 minutes (120 minutes for eligible PwD candidates)
Total Questions: 120 multiple-choice questions
Total Marks: 120 marks
Negative Marking: 0.33 marks per incorrect response
CBT-2 Subject Distribution
| Subject | Questions | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| General Awareness | 50 | 50 |
| Mathematics | 35 | 35 |
| General Intelligence & Reasoning | 35 | 35 |
| Total | 120 | 120 |
Increased Difficulty Level: CBT-2 questions are more challenging than CBT-1. The examination tests deeper understanding and advanced problem-solving abilities.
Syllabus Coverage: The syllabus remains similar to CBT-1 but requires comprehensive knowledge. Questions demand analytical thinking and conceptual clarity.
Time Management: With 90 minutes for 120 questions, candidates have 45 seconds per question. Efficient time allocation across sections becomes critical.
CBT-2 Preparation Strategy
Strengthen Core Concepts: Focus on fundamental principles in mathematics and reasoning. Build strong foundational knowledge for complex problem-solving.
Current Affairs Integration: Maintain daily current affairs updates covering national and international developments. Create monthly compilations for systematic revision.
Practice Mock Tests: Attempt full-length practice tests under timed conditions. Analyze performance patterns to identify improvement areas.
Railway-specific Knowledge: Study Indian Railways organization structure, railway zones, important stations, and railway terminology. This knowledge aids general awareness preparation.
Skill Test and Typing Assessment Requirements
Certain positions require skill tests following CBT-2 qualification. These assessments evaluate job-specific competencies necessary for role performance.
Typing Test Requirements
Applicable Positions: Junior Clerk cum Typist, Accounts Clerk cum Typist, Senior Clerk cum Typist, and related clerical positions.
English Typing Speed: 30 words per minute on computer
Hindi Typing Speed: 25 words per minute on computer
Test Duration: 10 minutes for typing speed assessment
Error Margin: Maximum 2% error rate permitted
Keyboard Type: QWERTY keyboard layout used for assessment
Computer-Based Aptitude Test (CBAT)
Applicable Positions: Traffic Assistant, Commercial cum Ticket Clerk, and Station Master positions.
Test Components:
- Following Directions: Understanding and executing sequential instructions
- Concentration Ability: Maintaining focus during repetitive tasks
- Memory Assessment: Short-term and working memory evaluation
- Spatial Reasoning: Visual-spatial problem-solving
- Perceptual Speed: Quick and accurate information processing
Test Duration: Approximately 60-90 minutes depending on test components
Scoring System: Percentile-based scoring with minimum qualifying standards
Purpose: CBAT evaluates cognitive abilities essential for operational railway positions requiring quick decision-making under pressure.
Document Verification Process: Requirements and Procedures
Candidates qualifying requisite selection stages undergo comprehensive document verification. This process authenticates candidate credentials and ensures eligibility compliance.
Essential Documents List
Educational Certificates:
- Class 10th certificate and mark sheet (age proof)
- Class 12th certificate and mark sheet (intermediate qualification)
- Graduation degree certificate and all semester mark sheets
- Provisional degree certificate (if final degree awaited)
- Educational equivalence certificate (for foreign degrees)
Identity Proof Documents:
- Aadhaar Card (mandatory)
- PAN Card (recommended)
- Voter ID Card (if available)
- Passport (if available)
- Driving License (alternative ID proof)
Category Certificates:
- Caste certificate for SC/ST/OBC candidates (issued by competent authority)
- OBC Non-Creamy Layer certificate (valid within financial year)
- EWS certificate for economically weaker sections (current financial year)
- Disability certificate for PwD candidates (minimum 40% disability)
Residence Proof:
- Domicile certificate (if applicable for specific posts)
- Ration card or electricity bill
- Bank passbook with address
Photograph Requirements:
- Recent passport-size photographs (10 copies)
- Photographs matching application submission
Additional Documents:
- Community certificate (if applicable)
- Ex-servicemen certificate (for ex-servicemen category)
- Medical fitness certificate (as per railway standards)
- Character certificate from educational institution
Document Verification Timeline
Document verification typically occurs 2-3 months after CBT-2 results. The Railway Recruitment Board publishes zone-wise schedules with specific dates and venues.
Candidates receive communication through registered email and SMS. Verification usually completes in 1-2 days per candidate. Multiple verification sessions accommodate large candidate numbers.
Original documents require presentation with self-attested photocopies. Discrepancies between original documents and application data may result in candidature cancellation.
Medical Examination: Standards and Procedures
Candidates successfully completing document verification undergo medical examinations. Railway medical standards ensure fitness for specific job requirements.
Medical Categories for Railway Posts
Category A1: Vision standards with minimal correction, normal color vision, adequate hearing. Required for Station Master, Traffic positions.
Category B1: Moderate vision correction permitted, normal color vision, adequate hearing. Applicable for clerical and accounts positions.
Category C: Relaxed standards for certain posts not involving train operations or safety-critical functions.
Medical Assessment Components
Visual Acuity Testing:
- Distant vision assessment for both eyes
- Near vision testing for reading and computer work
- Color vision testing (Ishihara plates method)
- Night vision assessment where applicable
Hearing Assessment:
- Conversational hearing test
- Audiometry for specific positions
- Speech discrimination ability
General Physical Examination:
- Height and weight measurement (BMI calculation)
- Blood pressure monitoring
- Cardiovascular system examination
- Respiratory system assessment
- Musculoskeletal examination
Laboratory Investigations:
- Blood hemoglobin and blood group
- Urine routine examination
- Chest X-ray
- ECG (electrocardiogram) where required
Medical Standards Compliance
Candidates should maintain general fitness throughout the selection process. Address any correctable conditions (vision correction, dental issues) before medical examination.
Railway medical boards conduct examinations. Candidates receive medical fitness certificates upon successful examination. Medical unfitness results in candidature rejection even after clearing written examinations.
Reservation Policy and Category Benefits
The Railway Recruitment Board follows constitutional reservation provisions for equitable representation across different social groups.
Reservation Percentages
| Category | Reservation Percentage |
|---|---|
| Scheduled Castes (SC) | 15% |
| Scheduled Tribes (ST) | 7.5% |
| Other Backward Classes (OBC) | 27% |
| Economically Weaker Sections (EWS) | 10% |
| Persons with Disabilities (PwD) | 4% (horizontal) |
| Ex-Servicemen | 10% (horizontal) |
Horizontal Reservation: PwD and Ex-Servicemen reservations apply across all categories (UR, OBC, SC, ST, EWS).
Certificate Validity Requirements
OBC Non-Creamy Layer Certificate: Must be issued during the current financial year (April 1 to March 31). Certificates from previous years are invalid.
EWS Certificate: Should be obtained in the current financial year showing family income below ₹8 lakhs annually.
Caste Certificates: SC/ST certificates remain valid if issued by competent authority (Tehsildar or above) without expiration date.
Disability Certificate: Issued by authorized medical board certifying minimum 40% disability.
Age Relaxation Benefits
| Category | Maximum Age Relaxation |
|---|---|
| SC/ST Candidates | 5 years |
| OBC Candidates | 3 years |
| PwD (General) | 10 years |
| PwD (OBC) | 13 years |
| PwD (SC/ST) | 15 years |
| Ex-Servicemen | Service duration + 3 years |
Age relaxation applies to maximum age limits. Candidates must meet minimum age requirements on the cut-off date specified in the notification.
Employment Benefits and Service Conditions
Railway employment offers comprehensive benefits beyond basic salary. These advantages make railway positions attractive career options.
Salary Components and Allowances
Basic Pay: Starting basic pay of ₹29,200 for graduate level positions
Dearness Allowance (DA): Currently 50% of basic pay, revised twice annually based on inflation
House Rent Allowance (HRA): 8%, 16%, or 24% of basic pay depending on posting city classification
Transport Allowance: ₹1,350 to ₹3,600 based on city classification
Other Allowances: Special duty allowances, night duty allowances, and position-specific allowances
Annual Salary Calculation Example (Graduate Level)
- Basic Pay: ₹29,200
- DA (50%): ₹14,600
- HRA (8% for small cities): ₹2,336
- Transport Allowance: ₹1,350
- Monthly Gross: ₹47,486
- Annual Gross: ₹5,69,832
These figures are indicative. Actual take-home salary varies based on deductions (income tax, provident fund, insurance).
Travel Concessions
Personal Travel: Unlimited free travel in second class across Indian Railways network
Family Travel: Dependent family members receive free travel benefits
Leave Travel Concession (LTC): Entitled to LTC for self and family once in four years
Privilege Pass: Officers and staff receive privilege passes for AC class travel
Medical Benefits
Employee Health: Complete medical coverage through railway hospitals and empaneled hospitals
Family Coverage: Spouse and dependent children covered under medical scheme
Cashless Treatment: Treatment at railway hospitals without upfront payment
Referral System: Access to specialized treatment centers and medical institutions
Housing and Accommodation
Railway Quarters: Subsidized residential accommodation based on designation
Rent: Nominal license fee (approximately 10% of basic pay)
Location: Accommodation near workplace reducing commute time
Waiting List: Accommodation subject to availability; private arrangements initially
Retirement Benefits
Pension Scheme: Defined benefit pension scheme ensuring post-retirement financial security
Gratuity: Lump sum payment calculated based on years of service
Provident Fund: Employee contribution with matching employer contribution
Leave Encashment: Payment for unutilized earned leave at retirement
Post-Retirement Medical: Continued medical benefits after retirement
Career Progression Opportunities
Railway service offers structured career advancement through various pathways. Employees can progress to senior positions through experience and departmental examinations.
Promotion Pathways
Time-Bound Promotions: Automatic progression after completing specific service duration
Departmental Examinations: Competitive examinations for promotional positions
Selection Boards: Interview-based selections for senior management positions
Lateral Movements: Opportunities to move across different railway departments
Sample Career Progression (Station Master Track)
| Position | Experience Required | Approximate Pay Level |
|---|---|---|
| Junior Station Master | Entry Level | Level 6 (₹29,200) |
| Station Master Grade-II | 3-5 years | Level 7 (₹44,900) |
| Station Master Grade-I | 8-10 years | Level 8 (₹47,600) |
| Assistant Station Superintendent | 12-15 years | Level 9 (₹53,100) |
| Station Superintendent | 15-20 years | Level 10 (₹56,100) |
Career progression depends on individual performance, departmental requirements, and examination success.
Training and Skill Development
Initial Training: Comprehensive induction training covering railway operations, rules, and procedures
On-the-Job Training: Practical exposure under experienced supervisors
Refresher Courses: Periodic training programs for skill updating
Specialized Training: Domain-specific advanced training programs
Management Development: Leadership and management training for senior roles
Important Preparation Resources and Study Materials
Candidates preparing for subsequent examination stages should utilize quality study resources. Multiple platforms offer preparation materials for railway examinations.
Official Resources
Railway Recruitment Board Websites: Official notifications, syllabus details, previous year papers, and examination guidelines available on RRB websites.
Railway Ministry Publications: Indian Railways publishes reference materials on railway operations, rules, and procedures.
Government Portals: Employment news and examination calendars from Ministry of Railways and Department of Personnel and Training.
Subject-wise Study Approach
General Awareness Preparation:
- Daily newspaper reading (national dailies)
- Monthly current affairs magazines
- Government scheme awareness
- Static GK (Indian geography, history, polity, economy)
- Railway-specific information
Mathematics Preparation:
- NCERT textbooks (Class 6-10 for fundamentals)
- Practice books with solved examples
- Previous year question papers
- Mock test series
- Shortcut techniques for quick calculation
Reasoning Preparation:
- Logical reasoning practice sets
- Verbal and non-verbal reasoning books
- Pattern recognition exercises
- Analytical ability development
- Regular practice for speed improvement
Online Preparation Platforms
Numerous educational technology platforms offer preparation courses. These platforms provide video lectures, practice questions, mock tests, and performance analytics.
Candidates should verify content quality and syllabus alignment before subscribing to paid platforms. Free resources from government portals and educational websites often suffice for thorough preparation.
Mock Test Strategy
Regular mock test practice helps in performance improvement. Attempt full-length tests under examination conditions (timed environment, no interruptions).
Analyze incorrect answers to understand mistakes. Review explanations for all questions, including correctly answered ones. Track performance trends across multiple mock tests.
Focus on weak areas identified through mock test analysis. Gradually improve accuracy and speed through consistent practice.
Common Mistakes to Avoid During Selection Process
Candidates should be aware of typical errors that affect selection prospects. Avoiding these mistakes improves success probability.
Application Stage Errors
Incorrect Personal Information: Errors in name, date of birth, or category create complications during verification.
Wrong Category Selection: Claiming incorrect reservation benefits leads to candidature cancellation.
Invalid Email/Phone: Using non-functional contact information prevents receiving important communications.
Document Mismatch: Variations between application data and actual certificates cause verification problems.
Examination Mistakes
Poor Time Management: Spending excessive time on difficult questions reduces overall attempt.
Ignoring Negative Marking: Random guessing without eliminating options increases negative scores.
Incomplete Attempt: Leaving easy questions unattempted while attempting difficult ones.
Technical Issues: Not familiarizing with computer-based test interface before examination.
Post-Result Errors
Missing Deadlines: Failing to respond to document verification calls or admission notices.
Incomplete Documentation: Not carrying all required documents to verification venues.
Certificate Issues: Expired or invalid certificates causing disqualification.
Medical Non-Compliance: Neglecting health conditions that affect medical examination clearance.
Transparency and Anti-Malpractice Measures
The Railway Recruitment Board maintains strict protocols ensuring examination integrity and transparency.
Examination Security Measures
Biometric Authentication: Fingerprint and photograph verification at examination centers
CCTV Surveillance: Continuous monitoring of examination halls
Random Seating: Computer-generated random seat allocation
Multi-level Invigilation: Central observers with hall invigilators
Post-Examination Analysis: Statistical analysis for detecting unfair means
Normalization Process
RRB conducts examinations in multiple sessions across different dates. Normalization ensures fairness by adjusting scores for difficulty variations across sessions.
The normalization formula considers each session’s performance distribution. This process ensures no candidate gains unfair advantage due to receiving easier question sets.
Grievance Redressal Mechanism
Online Complaint System: Web-based grievance submission portal
Designated Helplines: Telephone and email support for queries
Response Timeline: Acknowledgment within 3-5 working days
Escalation Process: Multi-tier grievance handling for unresolved issues
Candidates can raise concerns regarding examination conduct, result discrepancies, or procedural issues through official channels.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. When will RRB NTPC Graduate Level Result 2025 be declared?
The RRB NTPC Graduate Level Result 2025 is expected to be announced in September 2025. The specific result declaration date depends on evaluation completion following the CBT-1 examination conducted from August 7 to September 9, 2025.
Results will be published simultaneously on all regional Railway Recruitment Board websites including rrbcdg.gov.in and other zone-specific portals. Candidates should regularly check their respective RRB zone websites for official announcements.
Result notifications are also sent to registered email addresses and mobile numbers provided during application submission. The Railway Recruitment Board typically announces results through official press releases before making them available online.
2. How can I check my RRB NTPC CBT-1 result online?
To check RRB NTPC results, visit your examination zone’s official RRB website (for example, rrbcdg.gov.in for Chandigarh zone). Locate the result link under “Latest Updates” or “Results” section on the homepage. Click the “RRB NTPC Graduate Level CBT-1 Result 2025” link. Enter your registration number and date of birth in the specified format. Submit the information after verifying accuracy.
The system displays your result status, normalized marks, sectional scores, and CBT-2 qualification status. Download the scorecard PDF immediately and save multiple copies. The scorecard contains important information including your examination roll number, session details, raw scores, normalized marks, and cut-off marks for your category. Print the scorecard for document verification purposes.
3. What are the expected cut-off marks for different categories in RRB NTPC 2025?
Expected cut-off marks for RRB NTPC Graduate Level 2025 are approximately 68-75 marks for General category, 63-70 marks for OBC category, 58-65 marks for SC category, and 55-62 marks for ST category. EWS category cut-offs are expected around 65-72 marks.
These estimates are based on vacancy distribution, candidate performance patterns, and historical trends from previous recruitment cycles. Actual cut-offs vary across different railway zones based on regional competition levels.
Northern Railway, Central Railway, and Western Railway zones typically record higher cut-offs due to larger candidate pools and premium posting locations. Cut-off determination considers multiple factors including total vacancies, number of candidates appearing, examination difficulty level, and normalization across different examination sessions. Official cut-off marks are published with the result announcement on respective RRB websites.
4. What is the complete selection process after qualifying RRB NTPC CBT-1?
The selection process after CBT-1 includes Computer Based Test 2 (CBT-2), skill tests, document verification, and medical examination. CBT-2 contains 120 questions across General Awareness (50 questions), Mathematics (35 questions), and General Intelligence & Reasoning (35 questions) with increased difficulty compared to CBT-1.
Candidates qualifying CBT-2 undergo position-specific skill tests: typing test (30 WPM English, 25 WPM Hindi) for clerical positions or Computer Based Aptitude Test (CBAT) for operational positions like Station Master and Traffic Assistant. Document verification follows, requiring educational certificates, identity proof, category certificates, and other eligibility documents. The final stage is medical examination ensuring candidates meet railway medical standards for their designated category.
The entire selection process typically spans 6-9 months from CBT-1 results to final appointment. Final merit lists are prepared based on CBT-2 scores, with CBT-1 serving as screening examination only.
5. What documents are required for RRB NTPC document verification?
Essential documents for verification include educational certificates (Class 10th, 12th, graduation degree with all semester mark sheets), identity proof (Aadhaar card mandatory, plus PAN card, voter ID, or passport), and category certificates (SC/ST/OBC caste certificate, OBC non-creamy layer certificate issued in current financial year, EWS certificate for economically weaker sections, disability certificate for PwD candidates).
Additional requirements include recent passport-size photographs (10 copies matching application), community certificate if applicable, ex-servicemen certificate for ex-servicemen category, and medical fitness certificate. Candidates must present original documents along with self-attested photocopies. Domicile certificate may be required for specific positions with regional eligibility criteria. Any discrepancy between original documents and application data can result in candidature cancellation.
Candidates should organize documents systematically with proper labeling for smooth verification. The Railway Recruitment Board provides detailed document lists in verification call letters sent to qualified candidates.
6. What is the salary structure and benefits for RRB NTPC graduate level positions?
Graduate level positions in RRB NTPC start at ₹29,200 per month as basic pay (Level 6 in 7th Pay Commission). Including allowances, gross monthly salary ranges from ₹47,000-₹55,000 depending on posting location. Dearness Allowance (currently 50% of basic pay) is revised twice yearly based on inflation. House Rent Allowance ranges from 8% to 24% of basic pay based on city classification (X, Y, or Z class cities).
Transport allowance ranges from ₹1,350 to ₹3,600. Additional benefits include unlimited free travel for employee across Indian Railways, family travel concessions, comprehensive medical coverage for employee and dependents, subsidized accommodation in railway quarters, Leave Travel Concession (LTC) once in four years, and defined benefit pension scheme. Retirement benefits include gratuity, provident fund with employer contribution, leave encashment, and post-retirement medical facilities.
Career progression through departmental examinations and time-bound promotions offers salary growth to ₹50,000+ over years. The combination of stable salary, comprehensive benefits, and job security makes railway positions attractive long-term career options.
7. How does the normalization process work in RRB NTPC examinations?
Normalization adjusts candidate scores across different examination sessions to ensure fairness. Since RRB NTPC examinations are conducted in multiple sessions over several days, question papers vary across sessions with different difficulty levels.
The normalization process uses statistical methods considering average performance and standard deviation in each session. A candidate’s normalized score depends on their raw score, mean score of their session, and comparison with other sessions’ performance distributions. Candidates receiving relatively difficult question papers receive normalization benefits compared to those with easier papers. The process ensures that no candidate gains unfair advantage due to appearing in a particular session.
Formula-based calculation considers percentile performance within each session. The Railway Recruitment Board’s normalization methodology follows established psychometric principles used in large-scale competitive examinations. Final cut-offs and merit lists are prepared based on normalized marks, not raw scores. Scorecards display both raw marks and normalized marks for transparency. This process maintains examination integrity across multiple session administrations.
8. What career growth opportunities exist after joining through RRB NTPC?
Railway careers offer structured progression through time-bound promotions, departmental examinations, and selection boards. Initial positions at Level 6 (₹29,200 basic pay) progress to Level 7 after 3-5 years experience through time-bound promotion or departmental examination. Further advancement to Level 8, 9, and 10 occurs over 10-15 years based on performance and examination success. Station Master positions can progress to Assistant Station Superintendent and eventually Station Superintendent with commensurate salary increases.
Clerical positions advance to Senior Clerk, Head Clerk, and administrative positions. The railway system provides regular training including initial induction training, on-the-job training, refresher courses, and specialized skill development programs. Management development programs prepare employees for leadership roles. Lateral movement opportunities exist across different railway departments (commercial, operations, accounts, personnel).
Employees can appear for Railway Board examinations for Group A officer positions. Post-retirement benefits include pension, medical coverage, and railway travel concessions. The combination of job security, systematic career progression, comprehensive benefits, and social recognition makes railway careers suitable for long-term professional satisfaction and financial stability.
Conclusion: Key Takeaways and Next Steps
The RRB NTPC Graduate Level Result 2025 represents a significant milestone for candidates who appeared in CBT-1 examinations. With 8,113 graduate-level positions available and starting salaries of ₹29,200 per month, this recruitment offers substantial career opportunities within Indian Railways.
Understanding the complete selection process helps candidates prepare effectively for subsequent stages. CBT-2 qualification, skill tests, document verification, and medical examinations each require specific preparation and attention to requirements.
The Railway Recruitment Board maintains transparent processes with clearly defined evaluation criteria. Reservation policies ensure equitable representation across different social categories. Normalization procedures guarantee fairness across multiple examination sessions.
Immediate Action Steps for Candidates:
- Monitor official RRB websites regularly for result announcements
- Prepare for CBT-2 by strengthening core concepts across all subjects
- Organize all required documents for verification in advance
- Maintain physical fitness for medical examination standards
- Keep contact information updated for receiving official communications
- Review previous year CBT-2 question patterns for effective preparation
- Practice typing skills if applying for clerical positions
- Stay informed about railway operations and current developments
Long-term Career Planning:
Railway positions offer stable employment with comprehensive benefits. Career progression through departmental examinations and time-bound promotions provides long-term growth opportunities. The combination of job security, competitive salary, travel benefits, medical coverage, and retirement benefits makes railway careers attractive for sustained professional development.
Candidates should verify all information from official RRB sources.
Regular monitoring of official notifications ensures awareness of procedural updates and timeline changes.
Understanding the RRB NTPC Examination History and Evolution
The Non-Technical Popular Categories examination has evolved significantly over the years. Understanding this evolution provides context for current recruitment processes and helps candidates appreciate the examination’s structure.
Historical Background
The Railway Recruitment Board was established in 1998 to streamline railway recruitment processes. Prior to centralization, individual railway zones conducted separate recruitments, leading to inefficiencies and inconsistencies.
The NTPC category was created to consolidate multiple non-technical positions under a unified recruitment framework. This consolidation improved efficiency, reduced duplication, and ensured standardized selection criteria across all railway zones.
Early NTPC recruitments followed paper-based examination formats. The transition to Computer Based Tests began in 2015-2016, enhancing examination security, reducing evaluation time, and enabling multi-session examinations for large candidate pools.
Recent Recruitment Trends
Recent years have witnessed increasing candidate participation in railway examinations. The 2019-20 NTPC recruitment received over 1.26 crore (12.6 million) applications for approximately 35,000 positions, reflecting intense competition.
Digital transformation initiatives have streamlined application processes, result declarations, and candidate communications. Mobile-responsive websites and SMS notifications ensure timely information dissemination to candidates.
The introduction of normalization procedures addressed challenges of conducting examinations across multiple sessions. This methodology ensures fairness while accommodating large candidate numbers within reasonable timeframes.
Zone-wise Vacancy Analysis and Distribution
Understanding zone-wise vacancy distribution helps candidates make informed decisions about preferred posting locations and competition levels.
Major Railway Zones and Their Characteristics
Northern Railway (Headquarters: New Delhi) Northern Railway covers Delhi, Haryana, Punjab, Himachal Pradesh, Jammu & Kashmir, and parts of Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan. This zone typically offers substantial vacancies due to extensive network coverage and operational requirements. Competition levels remain high due to the zone’s perceived prestige and metropolitan posting locations.
Central Railway (Headquarters: Mumbai) Central Railway serves Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, and parts of Karnataka. The zone’s headquarters in Mumbai makes it attractive for candidates seeking metropolitan assignments. Vacancy numbers reflect the zone’s significant operational scale and passenger density.
Western Railway (Headquarters: Mumbai) Western Railway operates in Gujarat, Maharashtra, and Rajasthan. Industrial and commercial activities in these regions create substantial railway traffic, resulting in consistent staffing requirements and vacancy announcements.
Southern Railway (Headquarters: Chennai) Southern Railway covers Tamil Nadu, Kerala, parts of Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, and Puducherry. The zone’s extensive electrified network and high passenger volume necessitate regular recruitment of operational and administrative staff.
Eastern Railway (Headquarters: Kolkata) Eastern Railway operates in West Bengal, Bihar, and parts of Jharkhand and Odisha. The zone’s historical significance and continuing operational demands generate regular vacancy announcements across various categories.
South Central Railway (Headquarters: Secunderabad) South Central Railway serves Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, and parts of Maharashtra and Karnataka. The zone’s expanding network and infrastructure development projects create ongoing staffing requirements.
North Central Railway (Headquarters: Prayagraj/Allahabad) North Central Railway covers Uttar Pradesh with significant passenger and freight operations. The zone regularly announces vacancies across different NTPC categories.
Northeast Frontier Railway (Headquarters: Guwahati) Northeast Frontier Railway serves Assam, Tripura, and northeastern states. The zone’s challenging terrain and expanding network create unique operational requirements and staffing needs.
Vacancy Distribution Patterns
| Railway Zone | Approximate Graduate Vacancies | Competition Level |
|---|---|---|
| Northern Railway | 1,200-1,500 | Very High |
| Central Railway | 1,000-1,300 | High |
| Western Railway | 900-1,200 | High |
| Southern Railway | 800-1,100 | Moderate-High |
| Eastern Railway | 700-900 | Moderate |
| South Central Railway | 600-800 | Moderate |
| North Central Railway | 500-700 | Moderate |
| Northeast Frontier Railway | 300-500 | Moderate-Low |
These figures are indicative and vary based on operational requirements, retirement patterns, and expansion projects in each zone.
Understanding the Railway Organizational Structure
Familiarity with railway organizational structure helps candidates understand career progression pathways and functional responsibilities.
Administrative Hierarchy
Railway Board (Ministry of Railways): The apex body formulating policies, strategic planning, and resource allocation. Located in New Delhi, the Railway Board oversees all railway zones and production units.
Zonal Railways: Semi-autonomous units managing day-to-day operations within geographical jurisdictions. Each zone has a General Manager as administrative head.
Divisions: Operational units within zones handling specific geographical areas. Divisional Railway Managers oversee division-level operations.
Stations and Sections: Basic operational units where most NTPC positions function. Station Masters, Commercial Clerks, and other NTPC posts operate at this level.
Departmental Structure
Commercial Department: Handles passenger and freight revenue, ticketing operations, and customer services. Commercial Clerks and related NTPC positions function within this department.
Operating Department: Manages train operations, traffic control, and safety protocols. Station Masters, Traffic Assistants, and Goods Train Managers work in this department.
Accounts Department: Responsible for financial management, budgeting, and audit functions. Junior Accounts Assistants and Accounts Clerks operate within this department.
Personnel Department: Manages human resources, recruitment, training, and employee welfare. Administrative positions exist within this department.
Engineering Departments: Include Civil, Mechanical, Electrical, and Signal & Telecom engineering. While primarily technical, some administrative support positions exist.
Financial Planning for Railway Career Aspirants
Understanding complete financial implications helps candidates make informed career decisions and plan accordingly.
Initial Investment Requirements
Application Fee: Typically ₹500 for general category candidates, ₹250 for reserved categories. Fee exemptions apply for female candidates, SC/ST candidates, and economically disadvantaged groups.
Examination Preparation Costs:
- Study materials and books: ₹2,000-₹5,000
- Online course subscriptions (optional): ₹3,000-₹10,000
- Mock test series: ₹1,000-₹3,000
- Coaching classes (optional): ₹15,000-₹50,000
Travel Expenses: Examination centers, document verification, and medical examination may require travel. Budget ₹5,000-₹20,000 depending on location and distance.
Document Expenses: Certificate attestation, photographs, photocopies, and other documentation costs approximately ₹2,000-₹5,000.
Return on Investment Analysis
Time to First Salary: Approximately 10-15 months from application to joining (including all selection stages).
First Year Earnings: Approximately ₹5.5-₹6.5 lakhs gross annual salary including allowances.
Five-Year Cumulative Earnings: Approximately ₹35-₹40 lakhs including increments and promotions.
Lifetime Career Earnings: Estimated ₹2-₹3 crores over 35-year career including salary progression, promotions, and retirement benefits.
Non-Monetary Benefits Value: Medical coverage, travel concessions, housing subsidies, and other benefits worth approximately ₹2-₹3 lakhs annually.
Loan and Financial Assistance Options
Education Loans: Banks offer education loans for competitive examination preparation with moratorium periods until employment.
Government Schemes: Various central and state government schemes provide financial assistance for SC/ST/OBC candidates preparing for competitive examinations.
Scholarship Programs: Merit-based scholarships from private foundations and trusts support examination preparation for economically disadvantaged candidates.
Work-Life Balance in Railway Careers
Understanding work culture and lifestyle helps candidates set realistic expectations about railway employment.
Working Hours and Shifts
Regular Office Hours: Administrative and accounts positions typically follow 9:00 AM to 5:30 PM schedules with lunch breaks.
Shift Duties: Operational positions like Station Master and Traffic Assistant involve rotating shifts (morning, evening, night) to ensure 24/7 railway operations.
Weekly Off: Typically one day off per week, though operational staff may have irregular weekly offs based on duty rosters.
Overtime Compensation: Additional duty hours are compensated through overtime pay or compensatory offs.
Leave Entitlements
Earned Leave: 30 days annually, accumulating up to 300 days throughout career.
Casual Leave: 8-10 days annually for short-term absences.
Medical Leave: Granted based on medical certificates for illness or injury.
Maternity/Paternity Leave: 180 days maternity leave for female employees; 15 days paternity leave for male employees.
Special Leave: Available for specific circumstances like study leave, child care leave, or personal exigencies.
Work Culture and Environment
Railway work culture emphasizes discipline, punctuality, and hierarchical respect. The organizational structure follows clear reporting lines and procedural adherence.
Operational positions require decision-making under time pressure and managing emergency situations. Administrative positions involve routine tasks with periodic deadline pressures.
Transfer policies mean employees may work across different locations during their careers. Typically, transfers occur every 3-5 years, though preferences and personal circumstances receive consideration.
Workplace diversity has increased with growing female participation in railway services. Work environments increasingly emphasize gender sensitivity and inclusive practices.
Technology Integration in Modern Railway Operations
Understanding technological developments helps candidates prepare for contemporary railway work environments.
Digital Transformation Initiatives
Unreserved Ticketing System (UTS): Mobile application enabling paperless ticketing for unreserved travel. Staff interact with digital systems for ticket validation and revenue management.
Passenger Reservation System (PRS): Computerized reservation system handling millions of daily transactions. Commercial staff require familiarity with PRS operations.
Freight Operations Information System (FOIS): Tracks freight movement, wagon allocation, and cargo documentation. Goods Train Managers and Traffic staff use FOIS extensively.
Electronic Private Number (EPN) System: Digital communication system for train control and operations. Operational staff must understand EPN protocols.
Future Technology Trends
Artificial Intelligence Integration: AI applications in predictive maintenance, passenger flow management, and operational optimization are emerging.
Internet of Things (IoT): Sensor networks monitoring track conditions, rolling stock health, and station infrastructure are expanding.
Automated Fare Collection: Implementation of smart cards and contactless payment systems is progressing.
Train Management Systems: Advanced automation in train operations including automatic train protection and train collision avoidance systems.
Railway employees increasingly require digital literacy and adaptability to evolving technologies. Training programs incorporate technology skill development to prepare workforce for modernization initiatives.
Regional Language Considerations
Railway operations span diverse linguistic regions, requiring language adaptability.
Official Language Policy
Railway communication occurs in Hindi and English at official levels. Regional languages receive recognition for passenger communication and local operations.
Hindi remains the primary official language for northern and central zones. English serves as associate official language and link language across zones.
Southern zones extensively use regional languages (Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam) for local operations and passenger services. Bilingual or trilingual proficiency provides career advantages in these regions.
Language Requirements in Examinations
CBT-1 and CBT-2 examinations are available in multiple languages including Hindi, English, and major regional languages. Candidates select their preferred examination language during application.
General Awareness questions may include region-specific content, but technical and reasoning questions follow language-neutral formats where possible.
Typing tests evaluate proficiency in Hindi and English. Knowledge of regional languages is beneficial but not mandatory for most positions.
Communication Skills Development
Hindi Proficiency: Essential for communication in Hindi-speaking regions and official correspondence.
English Proficiency: Required for technical documentation, digital systems, and inter-zone communication.
Regional Language Knowledge: Advantageous for passenger interaction and local operational communication.
Training programs often include language skill development modules. Employee transfers across linguistic regions may necessitate learning new languages.
Women in Railway Services: Opportunities and Support
Railway services increasingly emphasize gender diversity and women’s participation.
Growing Female Representation
Recent recruitment cycles show increasing female candidature. The 2019-20 NTPC recruitment witnessed approximately 30% female applicants, demonstrating growing interest among women candidates.
Successful female candidates join across all NTPC categories including operational positions traditionally male-dominated. Station Masters, Traffic Assistants, and Commercial Clerks now include significant female representation.
Support Infrastructure
Separate Facilities: Railway stations and offices provide separate restrooms and changing facilities for female employees.
Maternity Benefits: Comprehensive maternity leave provisions (180 days) with job protection and career continuity.
Flexible Working: Where operationally feasible, flexible scheduling accommodates childcare and family responsibilities.
Safety Measures: Enhanced security protocols, grievance mechanisms, and anti-harassment policies protect female employees.
Women’s Welfare Organizations: Railway Women’s Welfare Organizations (RWWOs) provide community support, advocacy, and welfare services.
Career Success Stories
Numerous women have achieved senior positions within railway hierarchy. Female Divisional Railway Managers, Additional Divisional Railway Managers, and senior administrative officers demonstrate career advancement possibilities.
Railway recruitment follows merit-based selection without gender-based discrimination. Female candidates compete on equal terms with identical cut-offs and evaluation criteria.
Environmental and Social Responsibility in Railway Careers
Railway employment connects to broader environmental and social objectives.
Sustainable Transportation
Railways represent one of the most energy-efficient mass transportation modes. Railway employees contribute to sustainable development by facilitating eco-friendly travel alternatives to road and air transport.
Electrification initiatives reduce carbon emissions. Employees participate in operating increasingly electrified networks, supporting environmental goals.
Social Connectivity
Railways provide affordable transportation connecting remote regions to economic centers. Railway staff enable social mobility and economic access for millions of citizens daily.
Special provisions for senior citizens, persons with disabilities, and economically disadvantaged passengers implement inclusive transportation policies. Staff members facilitate these social welfare measures.
Community Development
Railway presence stimulates local economic development. Railway employees often engage in community welfare activities, adult education programs, and social development initiatives.
Railway schools, hospitals, and sports facilities serve not only railway families but often broader communities. Employees contribute to this social infrastructure.
Preparing for Unexpected Challenges
Candidates should anticipate and prepare for potential challenges during the recruitment process.
Technical Difficulties During Examinations
Computer-based tests may encounter technical issues like system freezes, power failures, or network problems. Examination centers have backup procedures, but candidates should remain calm and immediately notify invigilators of any technical problems.
Biometric authentication failures occasionally occur. Carrying multiple identity documents and original admit cards helps resolve authentication issues quickly.
Document-related Complications
Name variations across documents create verification problems. If your name appears differently on various certificates, obtain an affidavit explaining the variation before document verification.
Expired or invalid category certificates cause disqualifications. Verify certificate validity well before verification schedules. Obtain fresh certificates if existing ones approach expiration.
Lost or damaged original certificates require duplicates from issuing authorities. Begin duplicate certificate processes early as they may require several weeks.
Medical Examination Concerns
Candidates with pre-existing medical conditions should understand railway medical standards for their category. Correctable conditions (vision through spectacles, controlled blood pressure) generally don’t disqualify candidates if they meet specified standards.
Sudden illness before medical examination may require rescheduling. Contact the concerned Railway Recruitment Board immediately with medical documentation for rescheduling requests.
Communication Gaps
Candidates sometimes miss important notifications due to incorrect contact information or email filtering. Register official RRB email addresses as safe senders to prevent messages from reaching spam folders.
Maintain updated contact information throughout the recruitment process. Inform RRB promptly of any address, email, or phone number changes.
Final Preparation Checklist: 30 Days Before Result
Systematic preparation during the waiting period ensures readiness for subsequent stages.
Days 30-21: Foundation Building
- Review CBT-2 syllabus comprehensively
- Identify weak subject areas requiring focused attention
- Collect study materials, previous papers, and reference books
- Create a structured study schedule allocating time to each subject
- Begin current affairs compilation covering recent months
Days 20-11: Intensive Preparation
- Complete first-round syllabus coverage across all subjects
- Attempt subject-wise practice tests to assess understanding
- Focus on weak areas with additional study time
- Update current affairs notes with recent developments
- Organize all educational certificates and identity documents
Days 10-6: Mock Test Phase
- Attempt full-length CBT-2 mock tests under timed conditions
- Analyze performance identifying patterns and improvement areas
- Review incorrect answers and understand correct approaches
- Practice speed mathematics and reasoning shortcuts
- Prepare category certificates if not already available
Days 5-1: Final Preparations
- Light revision of key concepts and formulas
- Review current affairs compilation thoroughly
- Verify availability of all required documents
- Prepare document file with organized sections
- Get passport-size photographs if needed
- Maintain adequate rest and stress management
Result Declaration Day
- Check result early morning on official website
- Download and save scorecard immediately
- Verify all details on scorecard for accuracy
- Calculate approximate rank and cut-off position
- If qualified: Begin CBT-2 preparation immediately
- If not qualified: Analyze performance and plan for future attempts
About the Author
Nueplanet
Nueplanet is an educational content specialist with the years of experience covering government recruitment examinations and competitive test processes. Nueplanet specializes in analyzing railway recruitment patterns, examination structures, and career pathways.
Professional Background: Nueplanet has tracked Railway Recruitment Board processes since 2017, documenting recruitment cycles, analyzing selection trends, and studying policy developments. Nueplanet work focuses on providing factual, verified information sourced exclusively from official government notifications and railway board circulars.
Commitment to Accuracy: All information published undergoes rigorous verification against official Railway Recruitment Board notifications, Ministry of Railways announcements, and government gazette publications. Content accuracy is prioritized over publication speed to ensure readers receive reliable guidance.
Research Methodology: Information gathering involves daily monitoring of all 21 Railway Recruitment Board websites, Ministry of Railways press releases, parliamentary questions and answers regarding railway recruitment, and official railway statistical publications. Data verification occurs through cross-referencing multiple official sources before publication.
Transparency Statement: This website maintains independence from any coaching institutions, educational platforms, or commercial entities. No affiliate relationships exist that could compromise content objectivity. Revenue generation, if any, occurs only through ethical advertising compliant with platform policies.
About This Website:
This platform aims to provide accurate, up-to-date information about railway recruitment processes, examination patterns, and career opportunities within Indian Railways. Content serves educational purposes helping candidates understand complex recruitment procedures and make informed career decisions.
Editorial Policy:
- All dates, statistics, and procedural information sourced from official notifications
- Regular content updates reflecting official announcements and changes
- Clear distinction between confirmed information and expected/estimated data
- Correction policy: Errors corrected immediately upon identification with update notification
Last Content Verification: August 20, 2025
Originally Published: August 20, 2025
Contact for Corrections:
If you identify any factual inaccuracies or have official information contradicting published content, please submit correction requests through the website contact form with supporting official documentation. All legitimate corrections are implemented within 48 hours with public acknowledgment.
Disclaimer:
While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, candidates should verify all critical information from official Railway Recruitment Board sources before making decisions. This website provides informational content only and cannot be held liable for decisions made based on published information. Official RRB notifications supersede any information published here in case of discrepancies.
Helpful Resources
Call to Action
Stay tuned with NuePlanet.com for the latest updates on RRB NTPC Graduate Level Result 2025, cut-offs, and preparation strategies for CBT-2. Bookmark our site for timely insights on jobs, education, and recruitment news.
Latest Posts
- Dmart Share Price: Q1 Updates, Market Performance, and Investment Insights
- Delhi News: Latest Updates, Political Developments, and Weather Alerts
- Airtel Recharge Plan: Latest Offers, Benefits, and Bharti Airtel Share Price Insights
- NTPC: Powering India’s Energy Sector and Latest Updates
- Pimpri-Chinchwad Floods: Heavy Rainfall Triggers Chaos in Maharashtra






















Post Comment